The Complicated Life and Family of Claire Merritt Ruth

Claire Merritt Ruth 2

I keep returning to Claire Merritt Ruth because her life looks simple only from the outside. She was born Clara Mae Merritt, became Claire Merritt Hodgson after her first marriage, and after 1929 became Claire Merritt Ruth, the second wife of George Herman “Babe” Ruth. Her public story is polished legend. Her private story is a family ledger with erasures, disputed dates, and two daughters who remembered the same household differently.

A Birth Record With Two Clocks

I begin with her birth because even the calendar refuses to stand still. Her birth is reported as 11 September 1900 near Athens, Georgia, in her obituary, on her grave memorial, and in standard reference accounts. The Gate of Heaven headstone reads “Claire Ruth / 1900 to 1976.” A wedding day wire report from 17 April 1929 said the bride was 28. Her obituary said she was 76.

A competing date, 11 September 1897, appears in genealogical databases and some reference pages because the 1900 census lists a Clara Merrett already in the household of James M. Merrett. I treat 1897 as possible. I treat 1900 as what she, the press, and the grave chose to say. That gap of three years is small on paper and large in a life built on public performance.

She died on 25 October 1976 of cancer in her apartment at 110 Riverside Drive, New York. She did not remarry. She was buried at Gate of Heaven Cemetery in Hawthorne, New York, beside Babe Ruth. Her parents in genealogical compilations were James Monroe Merritt and Carrie Lou Rylee, also recorded as Riley or Ryler, who lived from about 1872 to 13 April 1943. Her brother H. L. Merritt was named in the 18 April 1929 wedding report. Attorney claims about her father were not confirmed in a contemporary document I opened.

The Hodgson Years and Julia

Her first marriage was to Frank Bishop Hodgson, born 25 December 1883. They married on 17 March 1915 in Clarke County, Georgia. He died on 16 February 1921. A 1929 wire story gave 1924 as his death year, but that is wrong. Their daughter, Julia Marshall Hodgson, was born on 7 July 1916 in Athens.

I see Julia as the stable hinge in Claire’s family story. Julia became Julia Ruth Stevens, the only biological child of Claire. Babe Ruth adopted her. Family accounts date the adoptions of Julia and Dorothy to about 30 October 1930. Julia later wrote three books on Ruth and died at 102 on 9 March 2019 in Henderson, Nevada. Her son Tom Stevens carried the family memory forward.

Claire met Ruth in 1923 while he was still married to Helen Woodford Ruth. Helen died on 11 January 1929 after a fire in Watertown, Massachusetts. Claire and Ruth married on 17 April 1929 at about 5:45 a.m. at the Church of St. Gregory the Great in New York. They remained married until Ruth died on 16 August 1948. Contemporaries cast Claire as the person who limited his drinking, eating, and spending. I think that role made her both guardian and gatekeeper, a woman holding a candle beside a hurricane.

The Family at a Glance

Name Relationship Dates and Notes
Clara Mae Merritt Birth name Born 11 September 1897 or 1900 near Athens, Georgia
Frank Bishop Hodgson First husband Born 25 December 1883, died 16 February 1921
Julia Marshall Hodgson Daughter Born 7 July 1916, died 9 March 2019
George Herman “Babe” Ruth Jr. Second husband Born 6 February 1895, died 16 August 1948
Helen Woodford Ruth Ruth’s first wife Died 11 January 1929
Dorothy Ruth Pirone Ruth’s biological daughter Born 7 June 1921, died 18 May 1989
Carrie Lou Merritt Claire’s mother About 1872 to 13 April 1943
H. L. Merritt Claire’s brother Named in the 18 April 1929 wedding report

The Two Daughters and the Gehrig Feud

Dorothy Ruth Pirone was Ruth’s biological daughter by Juanita Jennings. Babe and Helen adopted her in infancy. After Helen’s death, Dorothy lived with Ruth and Claire. Family histories say Claire adopted Dorothy in 1930. Dorothy later wrote that Claire favored Julia. That sentence is a small knife, and it cuts through the polished legend.

Claire’s 1960 will, later marked superseded, left Dorothy $100 and left Julia the trophies and personal effects. I do not read that as the final word on the family. I read it as the bluntest public document of how Claire ranked the two daughters at one moment. The final estate was not found.

Lou Gehrig and Christina Gehrig were not relatives, but they sit near the center of a feud Claire later blamed partly on herself. The dispute turned on how the two girls were dressed. They did not reconcile until Gehrig’s farewell in 1939. I see that feud as a domestic weather system that followed the Ruth household into public memory.

Career and Money and the Ruth Name

Claire worked as a model and stage performer from about 1920 to 1929. Her obituary said she modeled for Howard Chandler Christy and then danced in Broadway musicals. A 1929 wire report said that as Claire Merritt she was a Ziegfeld Follies showgirl and that before the stage she was an artist’s model whose face was said to have appeared on Liberty Loan posters. That poster claim was not tied to a specific museum caption. Film records say James Barton introduced her to Ruth while she was on tour with Dew Drop Inn.

On screen she appeared as herself in the 1932 short Fancy Curves. Later came Go to Bat for the Babe in 1951, The Steve Allen Show in 1956, and audience bows on The Ed Sullivan Show. From 1929 she managed Ruth’s private life. Auction descriptions of tax papers say a 1936 questionnaire listed her income as $10,000 and that Ruth deducted $10,000 for paying his wife as secretary. New York returns for 1939 to 1941 list falling secretary pay of $5,000, $3,600, and $3,000. I did not find whether the IRS allowed the deductions.

Year Reported Secretary Pay
1939 $5,000
1940 $3,600
1941 $3,000

One scholarly article using papers made available by Jane Leavy concludes that Ruth left “a substantial trust fund” to Claire. A dollar figure for that trust was not found. No verified net worth total was found. I see her finances as a ledger with a public column and a private column, and the private column is the one that keeps disappearing.

After 1948 she kept his name in public. She received an American Legion medal in 1949. She unveiled the Yankee Stadium monument on 19 April 1949. Babe Ruth Plaza was named on 17 August 1949. She supported Babe Ruth Leagues, a 1955 Baltimore plaque, and cancer society work. In 1974 she installed exhibits at the Babe Ruth Birthplace with Dorothy, Julia, and Ruth’s sister Mamie. Her book The Babe and I, written with Bill Slocum, was published by Prentice Hall in 1959. Her last public appearance was Old Timers’ Day at Yankee Stadium in August 1976.

She later said of Hank Aaron, “The Babe loved baseball so very much; I know he was pulling for Hank Aaron to break his record.” That quote sounds like a widow keeping a flame, not a curator keeping a file.

Public Memory and a Timeline

Modern memory keeps returning to her. The Babe Ruth Birthplace still credits Claire, Dorothy, Julia, and Mamie with the 1974 exhibits. A June 2025 Catholic Review article says a St. Mary’s photograph matches a plate in The Babe and I. Julia’s 2019 death renewed press portraits of Claire. Local Georgia columns in 2015 and 2019 record Rylee cousins’ oral history. No 2026 news story centered on Claire alone was found.

She has been portrayed by Claire Trevor in The Babe Ruth Story in 1948, Lisa Zane in Babe Ruth in 1991, Kelly McGillis in The Babe in 1992, and Renée Taylor in 61* in 2001.

Date Event
11 September 1897 or 1900 Birth in northeast Georgia
17 March 1915 Marriage to Frank Hodgson
7 July 1916 Julia born
16 February 1921 Hodgson dies
1923 Meets Ruth
11 January 1929 Helen Ruth dies
17 April 1929 Marriage to Babe Ruth
About 30 October 1930 Adoptions of Julia and Dorothy reported
16 August 1948 Ruth dies
19 April 1949 Unveils Yankee Stadium monument
1959 The Babe and I published
6 January 1960 Will signed, later marked superseded
July 1974 Birthplace museum exhibits open
25 October 1976 Dies and is buried beside Ruth
9 March 2019 Julia dies at 102

FAQ

Did Claire Merritt Ruth have children?

She had one biological child, Julia Marshall Hodgson, born on 7 July 1916 in Athens, Georgia. Julia became Julia Ruth Stevens and was adopted by Babe Ruth. Claire also helped raise Dorothy Ruth Pirone, Ruth’s biological daughter by Juanita Jennings, and family histories say Claire adopted Dorothy in 1930.

Why do records disagree about Claire’s birth year?

I find two clocks running at once. Her obituary, grave, and many public records favor 11 September 1900. The 1900 census lists a Clara Merrett already in the Merritt household, which supports 11 September 1897. I treat 1897 as possible and 1900 as the public date she and the press used.

What was Claire’s relationship with Dorothy Ruth Pirone?

Dorothy lived with Ruth and Claire after Helen Ruth died. Dorothy later wrote that Claire favored Julia. Claire’s 1960 will, later marked superseded, left Dorothy $100 and left Julia the trophies and personal effects. I see that will as a hard public trace of a complicated private ranking.

How did Claire manage Babe Ruth’s finances?

Contemporaries described her as the person who limited his drinking, eating, and spending. Tax paper descriptions say a 1936 questionnaire listed her income as $10,000 and that Ruth deducted $10,000 for paying his wife as secretary. New York returns for 1939 to 1941 list secretary pay of $5,000, $3,600, and $3,000. A dollar figure for the substantial trust Ruth left her was not found.

Where is Claire Merritt Ruth buried?

She died on 25 October 1976 in New York and was buried at Gate of Heaven Cemetery in Hawthorne, New York, beside Babe Ruth. The headstone reads “Claire Ruth / 1900 to 1976.”

0 Shares:
You May Also Like